Monthly Price Market Sell Buy Near Me Blog

Under Contract

MLS #: 1998159

Message Rob Save

3865 Broken Arrow, Peyton

Single Family in 80831

List Price

$575,000

Beds/Baths: 5/4

Garage: 2

Year Built: 1993

Days on Market: 39

Taxes: $2,209/yr

Insurance: $3,000/yr est.

Listed By: Shaina Glenn Real Estate

Estimated Monthly Cost Breakdown*

Mortgage (7.0% / 30yr) Contact a Lender → $3,825.49

Property Taxes $184.11

Insurance Get Quote → $250.00

Total Est. Monthly* $4,259.59

Market Context — 80831 (Falcon & Woodmen Hills)

Avg Days on Market: 77 ▼ This listing: 39

Avg Close Price: $578,000

Avg CPOLP: 96.6%

Median CPOLP: 97.3%

Active Listings: 208

Closed (30 days): 60

CPOLP = Close Price to Original List Price. Above 100% means sellers are getting more than asking. Based on closed sales in 80831 over the last 30 days.

County Assessor Data

Assessor Market Value: $503,972 14% above

Last Sale Price: $550,000

Last Sale Date: Aug 06, 2023

Lot Size: 2.60 acres

Finished SqFt: 2,195

Basement: 688 sqft (674 finished)

School District: EL PASO COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT #49

Source: El Paso County Assessor. Parcel 4325005002. Assessor values may differ from market value.

Hail Risk — 80831

High

Events (5 years): 17

Largest Stone: 2.0"

Avg Stone Size: 1.24"

Most Recent: Jul 06, 2025

Source: NOAA Storm Events Database. Hail events in this zip code over the past 5 years. Consider roof age and insurance implications.

Building Permits

14 records

Mar 2026 WATER HEATER REPLACEMENT $800 Finaled #Q30917

Aug 2022 REROOF $11,200 Finaled #O24407

Nov 2019 SIDING - REPLACE APPROX 7 SQUARES OF SIDING ON LEFT ELEVATION ONLY $3,300 Finaled #M59857

Oct 2018 BACKFLOW PREVENTER $500 Finaled #L87867

May 2018 DECK $7,700 Finaled #L49622

Showing 5 of 14 permits Provided as a courtesy — verify at pprbd.org

Recent Comparable Sales (30 Days)

9857 Morning Vista

5 bed / 4 bath · 76 DOM · Closed Feb 23

Listed: $575,000

$575,000

100.0% CPOLP

10853 Torreys Peak

5 bed / 4 bath · 13 DOM · Closed Feb 26

Listed: $594,900

$575,000

96.7% CPOLP

10753 Finsbury

4 bed / 3 bath · 5 DOM · Closed Feb 19

Listed: $571,990

$571,990

100.0% CPOLP

9812 Fairway Glen

5 bed / 3 bath · 44 DOM · Closed Feb 27

Listed: $569,999

$570,000

100.0% CPOLP

10126 Keating

4 bed / 3 bath · 27 DOM · Closed Feb 26

Listed: $569,950

$569,950

100.0% CPOLP

Based on closed sales in the last 30 days with similar price range and location.

Click here for full details on PPAR →

Call Rob Message Rob Get Alerts for 80831 Save

More Homes in 80831

MLS #: 1949298 More Details →

10102 Golf Crest, Peyton

Type: Single Family

Zip: 80831

Beds/Baths: 5/3

Garage: 2

List Price: $575,000

DOM: 5

Taxes: $3,867/yr

Year Built: 2015

Listed By: Homesmart Realty

List Price $575,000

Est. Monthly Cost* $4,397.73

Call Rob Message Rob Share Save ×

Price Drop — $105,100 off

MLS #: 1468482 More Details →

10489 Cedar Breaks, Peyton

Type: Single Family

Zip: 80831

Beds/Baths: 5/3

Garage: 3

List Price: $680,000 $574,900

DOM: 266

Taxes: $3,037/yr

Year Built: 2004

Listed By: Exp Realty LLC

List Price $574,900

Est. Monthly Cost* $4,327.91

Call Rob Message Rob Share Save ×

Price Drop — $20,000 off

MLS #: 6419314 More Details →

11232 Allendale, Peyton

Type: Single Family

Zip: 80831

Beds/Baths: 5/3

Garage: 2

List Price: $599,000 $579,000

DOM: 16

Taxes: $2,991/yr

Year Built: 2000

Listed By: MODUS Real Estate

List Price $579,000

Est. Monthly Cost* $4,351.35

Call Rob Message Rob Share Save ×

Price Drop — $15,000 off

MLS #: 1819499 More Details →

9647 Vistas Park, Peyton

Type: Single Family

Zip: 80831

Beds/Baths: 4/4

Garage: 2

List Price: $595,000 $580,000

DOM: 42

Taxes: $3,396/yr

Year Built: 2020

Listed By: True North Realty

List Price $580,000

Est. Monthly Cost* $4,391.75

Call Rob Message Rob Share Save ×

See all homes in 80831 →

Data from the PPMLS. Estimated monthly cost assumes 7.0% APR, 30-year fixed, $3,000/yr insurance, and actual taxes. This is not an offer to lend.

Save Your Favorites

Create a free account to save listings and get notified when new homes match your criteria.

No spam, just houses.

3865 Broken Arrow, Peyton

Estimated Monthly Cost Breakdown*

Market Context — 80831 (Falcon & Woodmen Hills)

County Assessor Data

Hail Risk — 80831

Building Permits

Recent Comparable Sales (30 Days)

More Homes in 80831

Send Rob a Message

Get Listing Alerts

Save Your Favorites

Get a Personalized Insurance Quote

Contact a Lender